Skip to content

RSUs and Bonuses Over $1 Million: The Mandatory 37% Withholding and Why You Still Owe at Tax Time (2026)

Lesser Tax cover: withheld 37%, still owe $142,866. Illustrative single filer with $1.3M of RSUs in 2026: first $1M withheld at 22% ($220,000), next $300,000 at 37% ($111,000), actual tax on RSUs $473,866
Lesser Tax

Lesser Tax

7 min read

Want an expert to handle this? Get your NRI taxes done right

Once the bonuses, RSU vests and other supplemental wages an employer pays you in a calendar year pass $1 million, federal law requires that employer to withhold exactly 37% on every supplemental dollar above $1 million, whatever your W-4 says. The first $1 million is usually still withheld at 22%, so the 37% rule shrinks your tax bill but rarely closes it. In our illustrative example, a single filer with a $300,000 salary and $1.3 million of RSUs in 2026 still owes about $142,866 when filing, even after 37% kicked in. Plan for it before December 31 and the January 15, 2027 estimated payment.

What is the $1 million supplemental wage rule?

The IRS splits your pay into two kinds. Regular wages are your fixed salary paid every pay period. Supplemental wages are everything else your employer pays: bonuses, commissions, back pay, RSU vests, NSO exercises and severance. IRS Publication 15 (2026) says the withholding rate on supplemental wages "remains 22%", and 37% once supplemental wages paid to an employee during the calendar year exceed $1 million.

The rule itself sits in Treasury Regulation 31.3402(g)-1(a)(2). Three details matter:

  • It is mandatory. The employer must apply 37%, the top rate under Section 1, "without regard to any entries on Form W-4", including a claim of exempt status.
  • Only the excess gets 37%. If one RSU release carries you from $800,000 to $1.2 million, the employer must apply 37% only to the $200,000 above $1 million. It may choose to apply 37% to the whole payment.
  • Only supplemental wages count. Your base salary does not count toward the $1 million. The regulation's own example says the amount of regular wages "is irrelevant" to when the 37% rate starts.

Why does 37% withholding still leave a tax bill?

Because the 37% applies only to dollars above $1 million. Everything below it is usually withheld at a flat 22%, but if you earn enough to cross $1 million of supplemental pay, most of that income is taxed at 35% or 37%. For 2026 the 35% bracket starts at $256,225 of taxable income for single filers and the 37% bracket at $640,600 ($768,700 for married couples filing jointly). The flat 22% rate is not adjusted for your bracket, so each of those first million dollars is under-withheld by up to 15 percentage points.

Your regular salary withholding follows your W-4 and is not part of this gap. If you want the background on how the 22% gap works at smaller amounts, read our guide to the RSU withholding gap and the January 15 safe harbor.

A worked example with 2026 figures

This example is illustrative, not a real client. Priya is single and works at a newly public tech company. In 2026 she earns a $300,000 salary and $1.3 million of RSU income from four vests: $300,000 in February, $400,000 in May, $500,000 in August and $100,000 in November. She takes the $16,100 standard deduction and has no other income.

  1. February and May vests ($700,000): withheld at 22%, which is $154,000.
  2. August vest ($500,000): the first $300,000 brings her to exactly $1 million and is withheld at 22% ($66,000). The remaining $200,000 is withheld at 37% ($74,000).
  3. November vest ($100,000): all of it is above $1 million, so 37% ($37,000).
  4. Total federal income tax withheld on the RSUs: $220,000 at 22% plus $111,000 at 37%, which is $331,000.

Now the actual tax. With $1.6 million of wages, her 2026 taxable income is $1,583,900 and her federal income tax is about $542,000. On her salary alone it would be about $68,134. So the RSUs add about $473,866 of federal income tax, roughly 36.5% of the RSU income. Withholding covered $331,000 of that, which leaves about $142,866 due when she files, assuming her salary withholding covers the tax on her salary.

Without the 37% rule, all $1.3 million would have been withheld at 22% ($286,000) and the shortfall would be about $187,866. The rule helped by $45,000, but it did not fix the problem.

Two more payroll lines move in this example. Medicare tax is 1.45% on all wages plus the 0.9% Additional Medicare Tax, which employers must withhold on wages above $200,000 regardless of filing status. Social Security tax stops once wages reach the 2026 wage base of $184,500, so her RSU income has no Social Security tax at all. Our guide to where your paycheck goes explains each line on the paystub.

Under $1 million vs over $1 million: what changes

ItemUnder $1 million of supplemental wagesAbove $1 million
Federal withholding on bonuses and RSUs22% flat (or the W-4 based aggregate method)37%, mandatory
Does your W-4 change it?Only if payroll uses the aggregate methodNo, W-4 entries and exempt status are ignored
Base salary withholdingFollows your W-4Still follows your W-4
Social Security tax6.2% on wages up to $184,500Same; usually already maxed out
Medicare tax1.45%, plus 0.9% on wages over $200,000Same
Likely balance due at filingYes, if you are in the 24% bracket or higherUsually yes, from the first $1 million

Who crosses $1 million without noticing?

The threshold is easier to reach than it sounds, especially in an IPO year:

  • Employees at a company that just went public. Double-trigger RSUs that built up for years can all settle in the first months after the IPO, so a single release can be larger than a normal year of salary. Our post on Anthropic IPO taxes for employees shows how one company's prospectus handles this.
  • Senior engineers and managers with large refreshers at a share price that rose during the year.
  • Sales leaders with large commissions, which are also supplemental wages.
  • Anyone with severance plus a final RSU release in the same calendar year.

What if you changed jobs this year?

Each employer counts its own supplemental payments. Companies under common control count as one employer, and a payroll agent's payments count as the employer's, but two unrelated employers do not add up. If you received $700,000 of RSUs at your old job and $700,000 at your new one, neither employer reaches $1 million, both withhold 22%, and your gap is larger than if one employer had paid it all. Our guide to changing jobs on an H-1B with two W-2s covers the other withholding problems a mid-year move causes.

Does this apply on an H-1B or a green card?

Yes. If you are a US tax resident, which most H-1B workers are once they pass the substantial presence test, and every green card holder is, the same supplemental wage rules apply to you as to a US citizen. The bracket figures above are for 2026; the 2027 brackets move the 37% line to $661,375 for single filers, but the 22% and 37% withholding rates stay the same.

What about state withholding?

States set their own rules. California, for example, withholds a flat 10.23% on bonuses and stock option income, which is below the rate most people with $1 million of supplemental wages actually pay in California. Expect a state balance due as well, and check your own state's supplemental rate.

What to do this week

  1. By November 30: open your latest paystub or equity statement and add up the year-to-date supplemental wages from this employer: bonuses, RSU income and commissions. Note how much was withheld at 22% and how much at 37%.
  2. Before your December paychecks: estimate your full 2026 tax. If the gap is large, give payroll a new W-4 with an extra amount in Step 4(c). Employers have up to about 30 days to apply a new W-4, so do it now if you want it on December pay. Withholding counts as paid evenly through the year, so extra withholding in December can still reduce an underpayment penalty for earlier quarters.
  3. Before December 31: if you plan to sell shares in a later year, remember that the tax on the vest is already locked in. Selling vested shares does not change the wage income on your W-2.
  4. By January 15, 2027: make a fourth-quarter estimated payment for anything withholding will not cover. If your 2025 adjusted gross income was over $150,000, paying in at least 110% of your 2025 tax through withholding and estimates generally avoids the underpayment penalty.
  5. By April 15, 2027: file and pay any balance due.

If you want someone to run these numbers with you, Lesser Tax does tax planning for tech employees with RSUs, ISOs and ESPP. This post is general information, not personal tax advice.

Lesser Tax

Lesser Tax

Written by

Sources

  1. 0126 CFR 31.3402(g)-1, supplemental wage payments (Cornell LII)law.cornell.edu ↗
  2. 02IRS Publication 15 (2026), Employer's Tax Guideirs.gov ↗
  3. 03IRS: Questions and Answers for the Additional Medicare Taxirs.gov ↗
  4. 04IRS Publication 505, Tax Withholding and Estimated Taxirs.gov ↗